Protection of Trade Marks Registered in Türkiye under European Legislation
Muhammed Bulgur
An Analysis of the Madrid Protocol, Regulation (EU) 2017/1001 on the European Union Trade Mark and the Paris Convention
Summary
A trade mark right is, in principle, valid only within the borders of the country in which it is registered. Accordingly, a registration in Türkiye does not automatically confer protection in Europe. Three routes are available for protection in Europe: The Madrid System, which is based on an application or registration in Türkiye; the European Union trade mark, which covers the entire European Union with a single registration; and national applications filed country by country. An application or registration in Türkiye is a prerequisite only under the Madrid System; however, under every route, a six-month priority period runs from the filing date of the application in Türkiye. This article seeks to set out the legal basis, the application procedure and the effect of each route.
The information in this article is current as of the date of publication; however, legislation is constantly evolving and changing. It is important to verify current legislation and obtain legal advice before taking any action. In addition, not all topics are covered in this article; after providing basic information, attention has been drawn to matters that I personally consider important for personal or professional reasons, and the article in this form does not constitute legal advice.
For the Turkish version of this article, see Türkiye’de Tescilli Markaların Avrupa Mevzuatları Çerçevesinde Korunması
I. INTRODUCTION
Consider the following scenario: A cosmetics brand you founded in Istanbul has established itself in the domestic market, and your products have begun to appear on the shelves of distributors in Germany and the Netherlands. Your trade mark is registered in Türkiye, and you assume that this registration also protects you in Europe. One day, news arrives from your distributor in Germany: A local company has registered the same name in its own name and is demanding that the sale of your products be stopped.
This picture illustrates a reality that many Turkish companies expanding abroad realize too late. As a rule, a trade mark right is valid only within the borders of the country in which it is registered. A registration in Türkiye does not automatically confer protection in Europe.
In this article, we will seek to set out, by reference to the legislation and the procedure, the routes through which a trade mark registered in Türkiye can be registered and protected in Europe. In brief, these routes are as follows:
- The European Union trade mark, which covers the entire European Union with a single application,
- The Madrid System, which makes it possible to request protection in more than one country on the basis of the application in Türkiye,
- National applications filed country by country.
Before examining these steps one by one, an important question must be answered: Does the protection regime we choose in Europe require the trade mark to be registered in Türkiye? The answer to this question largely determines the procedure and the ease with which protection can be obtained.
II. IS REGISTRATION IN TÜRKİYE A PREREQUISITE?
Most trade mark owners seeking protection in Europe believe that they must start with their registration in Türkiye. This belief is partly correct. Whether a registration or an application in Türkiye is a prerequisite depends on the route chosen.
A. The Madrid System
The Madrid System is a system that makes it possible to request protection in more than one country through a single international application. For this system to operate, a “basic mark” is required. Under Article 2 of the Madrid Protocol1, an international application must be based on an application filed with, or a registration obtained at, the office of origin.
In Turkish law, Article 25 of the Regulation on the Implementation of the Industrial Property Law2 likewise provides that such a request is to be made on the basis of a trade mark that is pending as an application before the Turkish Patent and Trademark Office (TÜRKPATENT) or is registered. We will examine the details of this route later in the article.
B. European Union Trade Mark And National Applications
Under Article 5 of Regulation (EU) 2017/1001 on the European Union Trade Mark3, any natural or legal person may be the proprietor of a European Union trade mark. No registration or application in Türkiye is required in order to file.
However, under Article 119/2, applicants who have neither their domicile nor their principal place of business nor a real and effective industrial or commercial establishment in the European Economic Area must be represented by a professional representative in proceedings before the European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO). Turkish companies that have no branch in these countries also fall within this scope. In other words, a Turkish company may complete and submit the application form itself, but it must conduct every step after filing through a lawyer or trade mark attorney established in the European Economic Area and entitled to act before the EUIPO. The exception is representation through an employee of a legal person established in the European Economic Area that has economic connections with the company.
The position is the same for national applications filed country by country. Under Article 6/2 of the Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property4, an application filed in one country may not be refused on the ground that no filing or registration has been effected in the country of origin. Under the third paragraph of the same article, a registration in each country is independent of the others.
C. Why Does The Application In Türkiye Matter Even Though It Is Not A Prerequisite?
The fact that an application in Türkiye is not a requirement under these routes does not mean that it is unimportant. Under Article 4 of the Paris Convention, applications filed in Europe for the same mark and the same goods and services within six months of the first application in Türkiye are treated as if they had been filed on the filing date of the application in Türkiye. This is called the right of priority.
Right of priority: The treatment of applications filed for the same mark and the same goods and services within six months of the first application in Türkiye as if they had been filed on the filing date of that application.
Article 34 of Regulation (EU) 2017/1001 also expressly recognizes this right. Applications by third parties filed in Europe during this six-month period cannot take precedence over the application concerned.
Ultimately, a strict prerequisite exists only for the Madrid System. However, whichever route is chosen, the application in Türkiye is the first step of the European strategy. It should be borne in mind that a six-month period begins to run from the filing date of the application in Türkiye. If this period is missed, the precedence arising from priority is also lost.
III. TRADE MARK PROTECTION REGIMES IN EUROPE
Now that we have clarified the question of registration in Türkiye, we can move on to examining the application routes separately. Below, we will scrutinize the legal basis, the application procedure and the effect of each protection regime one by one.
A. The Madrid System
The Madrid System is based on the Protocol Relating to the Madrid Agreement Concerning the International Registration of Marks (the Madrid Protocol). Türkiye is a party to this Protocol, and the Protocol entered into force with respect to Türkiye on 1 January 1999.
The most important feature of the system from a European perspective is this: Since the European Union is also a party to the Protocol, protection can be requested through a single application both for the entire EU and for non-EU European countries such as the United Kingdom, Switzerland or Norway. The application of the Protocol in domestic law is governed by the Regulation on the Implementation of the Industrial Property Law and the Regulation on the Implementation of the Madrid Agreement Concerning the International Registration of Marks and the Protocol Relating to that Agreement5.
The international application is filed not directly with WIPO but with TÜRKPATENT in its capacity as the office of origin. TÜRKPATENT examines the application and forwards it to the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO). Three documents are required for this purpose:
- TÜRKPATENT’s request form,
- WIPO’s official form, completed in English,
- Information showing that the transmittal fee payable to TÜRKPATENT has been paid.
As stated in the previous section, the application must be based on the application or registration in Türkiye. The sign must be identical to that in Türkiye, and the list of goods and services must not exceed the scope of the trade mark in Türkiye.
An international registration does not, by itself, give rise to a “European trade mark”. Under Article 4 of the Madrid Protocol, this registration is treated in each country designated in the application as if it had been filed directly with the trade mark registration authority of that country. In other words, the application is a single file, but the office of each country decides separately, under its own law, whether protection is to be granted.
As a rule, offices must notify their refusals within one year. Some parties have extended this period to 18 months. The European Union has also made this extension declaration. A refusal in one country does not affect protection in the other countries.
The term of protection is ten years, and renewal is effected not separately in each country but through a single procedure via WIPO. A country not designated in the application may also be added subsequently, when the business expands there.
Under Article 6/3 of the Protocol, the international registration remains dependent on the basic mark in Türkiye for five years from the date of registration. If, within this period, the application in Türkiye is withdrawn or refused, or the registration is cancelled, invalidated or not renewed, the protection in Europe falls to the same extent. Proceedings that begin within the five years and are concluded afterwards produce the same result. In other words, a weak trade mark in Türkiye that is open to challenge drags the protection in Europe down with it.
There is a mechanism that mitigates this risk. Under Article 9quinquies, the trade mark owner may, within three months, transform the cancelled international registration into national applications in the countries concerned and retain the original date.
B. The European Union Trade Mark
The European Union trade mark is a type of trade mark governed by Regulation (EU) 2017/1001 that provides protection in all 27 member states of the Union through a single registration. Article 1/2 of the Regulation sets out the unitary character of this trade mark. Accordingly, an EU trade mark has equal effect throughout the Union and may be registered, transferred or declared invalid only in respect of the whole Union. In other words, an EU trade mark is not a bundle of 27 separate registrations but a single right throughout the Union.
An important consequence of this is the following: The EU trade mark does not cover European countries that are not members of the Union, such as the United Kingdom, Switzerland and Norway. Separate applications must be filed for these countries.
Unlike under the Madrid System, the application is filed not through TÜRKPATENT but directly with the European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) in Alicante, Spain. As stated in the previous section, a Turkish company may submit the application form itself, but conducts the subsequent steps through a representative established in the European Economic Area.
The application is filed in one of the official languages of the Union. The applicant must also indicate one of the Office’s five working languages (English, French, German, Italian, Spanish) as a second language. Goods and services are specified according to the Nice Classification, as in Türkiye.
The EUIPO examines the application of its own motion for the absolute grounds for refusal listed in Article 7 of the Regulation. Being devoid of any distinctive character or describing the characteristics of the goods are foremost among these grounds. This is where the first consequence of the unitary character emerges.
Under the second paragraph of the same article, the application is refused even if the ground for refusal obtains in only part of the Union. For instance, even if your trade mark is distinctive in Turkish, if it corresponds to a word that describes the characteristics of the goods in Greek or Polish, you may face a refusal for the entire Union.
Earlier trade marks, by contrast, are not examined by the EUIPO of its own motion, but are taken into account upon opposition by the right holder. The EU system departs from the Turkish system at this point: In Türkiye, applications that are identical with, or indistinguishably similar to, an earlier trade mark are refused by TÜRKPATENT of its own motion.
Under Article 46, an opposition must be filed within three months of the publication of the application. The point to note here is this: The right of opposition is granted to anyone who holds an earlier trade mark right in any of the 27 member states. In other words, an earlier trade mark registered in a single country can halt the EU application as a whole.
Under Article 52 of the Regulation, a registered EU trade mark is protected for ten years from the filing date and may be renewed for further periods of ten years. The proprietor holds the rights conferred by the trade mark throughout the Union. Infringement actions, in turn, are heard by the courts that member states have designated as “EU trade mark courts”.
The obligation of use exists here as well, just as it does in our own legislation. Under Article 18 and, by its reference, Article 58/1-a, a trade mark that has not been put to genuine use in the Union within five years of registration is liable to revocation.
We mentioned that a ground for refusal or an earlier right in a single member state can bring down the EU trade mark as a whole. The mechanism that mitigates this risk is similar to the transformation we saw under the Madrid System. Under Article 139 of the Regulation, an EU trade mark application or an EU trade mark that has been refused or has ceased to have effect may, within three months, be converted into national applications in the member states where the ground for refusal does not exist. These national applications retain the date of the EU application.
C. National Applications
The third route is to file a separate application with the trade mark office of each country in which protection is sought. The legal basis of this route is the trade mark legislation of each country. However, the trade mark laws of EU member states have been approximated to a large extent by Directive (EU) 2015/2436 to Approximate the Laws of the Member States Relating to Trade Marks6. Belgium, the Netherlands and Luxembourg, on the other hand, are protected not separately but through a single application via the joint Benelux Office for Intellectual Property.
In each country, the application is filed in the language accepted by that country’s office, in accordance with its own procedural rules and upon payment of its own fees. Foreign applicants are often required to act through a representative established in that country or in the European Economic Area. The right of priority may also be relied upon for national applications filed within six months of the application in Türkiye.
The effect of a national registration is confined to the borders of that country. As stated in the previous section, each national registration is independent of the others. In other words, a refusal or invalidation in one country does not affect protection in the other countries.
Where more than one country is targeted, this route is both more costly and more burdensome to monitor than the other two. On the other hand, if business is to be conducted in only one or two countries, this third route may be the most reasonable one. If an EU trade mark has fallen because of an obstacle in one member state, national protection must be pursued not through a new application but through the conversion described above. This is because a new national application would lose the date of the EU application.
IV. CONCLUSION
Ultimately, there is no single correct route for protecting a trade mark registered in Türkiye in Europe. The markets targeted by the trade mark owner determine which route should be chosen. If business is to be conducted in most of the Union, the European Union trade mark comes to the fore; if European countries outside the Union are also targeted and the trade mark in Türkiye is sound, the Madrid System comes to the fore. If sales are to be made in only one or two countries, a national application may suffice.
However, whichever route is chosen, protection in Europe cannot be considered independently of the application in Türkiye. This application is the mandatory basis under the Madrid System and the source of the right of priority under the other routes.
It should be borne in mind that precedence in a trade mark is determined not when the products reach the shelves, but when the application is filed. The news from the distributor in the scenario at the beginning of the article is often the result of a period in which the application abroad was postponed or disregarded. Therefore, as soon as the decision to expand into Europe is taken, the trade mark strategy should be built from the outset, taking into account the six-month period that begins to run from the filing date of the application in Türkiye.
For related writing you may refer to our Employment, IP & Data service page.
Att. Muhammed Bulgur
This article was originally published at www.kstlawfirm.com
mbulgur@kstlawfirm.com
Legal References
1. Protocol Relating to the Madrid Agreement Concerning the International Registration of Marks (Madrid Protocol), adopted at Madrid on 27 June 1989, at wipo.int
2. Regulation on the Implementation of the Industrial Property Law (Sınai Mülkiyet Kanununun Uygulanmasına Dair Yönetmelik), Türkiye, Official Gazette of 24 April 2017, No. 30047; consolidated text at mevzuat.gov.tr
3. Regulation (EU) 2017/1001 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 14 June 2017 on the European Union trade mark, at eur-lex.europa.eu
4. Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property of 20 March 1883, at wipo.int
5. Regulation on the Implementation of the Madrid Agreement Concerning the International Registration of Marks and the Protocol Relating to that Agreement (Markaların Uluslararası Tesciline İlişkin Madrid Anlaşması ve Bu Anlaşmaya İlişkin Protokolün Uygulanmasına Dair Yönetmelik), Türkiye, Official Gazette of 12 March 1999, No. 23637, at resmigazete.gov.tr
6. Directive (EU) 2015/2436 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 16 December 2015 to approximate the laws of the Member States relating to trade marks, at eur-lex.europa.eu